Learn more
These promotions will be applied to this item:
Some promotions may be combined; others are not eligible to be combined with other offers. For details, please see the Terms & Conditions associated with these promotions.
Your Memberships & Subscriptions

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Follow the author
OK
The Matter With Things: Our Brains, Our Delusions and the Unmaking of the World Kindle Edition
Is the world essentially inert and mechanical - nothing but a collection of things for us to use? Are we ourselves nothing but the playthings of chance, embroiled in a war of all against all? Why, indeed, are we engaged in destroying everything that is valuable to us?
In his international bestseller, The Master and his Emissary, McGilchrist demonstrated that each brain hemisphere provides us with a radically different 'take' on the world, and used this insight to deliver a fresh understanding of the main turning points in the history of Western civilisation.
Twice before, in ancient Greece and Rome, the perception that evolved in the left hemisphere, which empowered us to manipulate the world, had ultimately come to eclipse the much more sophisticated take of the right hemisphere, which enabled us to understand it.
On each occasion this heralded the collapse of a civilisation. And now it was happening for a third, and possibly last, time.
In this landmark new book, Iain McGilchrist addresses some of the oldest and hardest questions humanity faces - ones that, however, have a practical urgency for all of us today.
Who are we? What is the world?
How can we understand consciousness, matter, space and time?
Is the cosmos without purpose or value?
Can we really neglect the sacred and divine?
In doing so, he argues that we have become enslaved to an account of things dominated by the brain's left hemisphere, one that blinds us to an awe-inspiring reality that is all around us, had we but eyes to see it.
He suggests that in order to understand ourselves and the world we need science and intuition, reason and imagination, not just one or two; that they are in any case far from being in conflict; and that the brain's right hemisphere plays the most important part in each.
And he shows us how to recognise the 'signature' of the left hemisphere in our thinking, so as to avoid making decisions that bring disaster in their wake. Following the paths of cutting-edge neurology, philosophy and physics, he reveals how each leads us to a similar vision of the world, one that is both profound and beautiful - and happens to be in line with the deepest traditions of human wisdom.
It is a vision that returns the world to life, and us to a better way of living in it: one we must embrace if we are to survive.
Please use the latest version of the Kindle app for the best reading experience of this book if you are using a non-Kindle device. If using a Kindle device, software updates are automatically downloaded and installed on your Kindle when it's connected wirelessly.
- LanguageEnglish
- Publication dateNovember 9, 2021
- File size26.6 MB
Customers who bought this item also bought
- Total independence is an imaginary construct, the limit case of interdependence, which is universal.Highlighted by 1,020 Kindle readers
- I believe that nowadays we live no longer in the presence of the world, but rather in a re-presentation of it. The significance of that is that the left hemisphere’s task is to ‘re-present’ what first ‘presences’ to the right hemisphere.Highlighted by 867 Kindle readers
- Two important truths, then: science cannot tell us everything; but what science can tell us is pure gold.Highlighted by 841 Kindle readers
Editorial Reviews
Review
—Professor Charles Foster, Oxford University, author of Being a Beast and Being a Human
'A work of remarkable inspiration and erudition, written with the soul and subtlety of a poet, the precision of a philosopher, and the no-nonsense grounding of a true scientist. In its pages, neuropsychology comes into conversation with philosophy, physics with poetry ... McGilchrist is the most generous and talented of writers: his fluid account, brilliantly and beautifully argued—and meticulously researched—brings us along with him, step by step, until we too can discern the horizons of a reconfigured world. McGilchrist's appreciation of ambiguity and paradox only enhances the clarity and vitality of his thought. This is a book of surpassing, even world-historical ambition, and—still more rare—one that delivers on its promise.'
—Professor Louis Sass, Distinguished Professor, Rutgers University, author of Madness & Modernism
'We badly need that now-almost-vanishingly rare personage, the true polymath. In Iain McGilchrist, in the nick of time, we have one. In this book, he draws quite magnificently on his post-disciplinary erudition precisely to explain how very much we are losing ... it is nothing less than a work of genius, diagnosing our dire predicament in full, and offering a way, instead.'
—Professor Rupert Read, Professor of Philosophy, University of East Anglia, author of This Civilisation is Finished and Parents for a Future
'A magnificent achievement ... The Matter with Things confirms the author's status as a leading contemporary polymath. With rarely matched clarity as well as deep learning, McGilchrist demonstrates not just that there is more to the world than matter, but also that there is more to matter itself than grasped by the shallow materialisms of our age.'
—Rupert Shortt, Von Hügel Institute, University of Cambridge, author of Outgrowing Dawkins
'I loved The Master and his Emissary: this is even deeper.'
—Professor Nassim Nicholas Taleb, NYU, author of The Black Swan
'In 2009 Iain McGilchrist published The Master and His Emissary, a densely researched and entirely thrilling examination of the difference between the two kinds of thinking typical of the right and left hemispheres of the brain. Now comes his new book, The Matter with Things (Perspectiva Press), which takes that basic idea much further and demonstrates, with an immense range of learning and beautifully clear prose, how important it is to be aware of the whole and not merely the parts, how analysis should come after insight and not before it, how right-hemisphere thinking, with its openness to experience, is a better guide to reality than the narrowly focused, rule-based way the left hemisphere regards the world ...I have spent a decade absorbing the vision of McGilchrist's previous book; I shall be happy to spend the rest of my life with this one, and still be learning things when I get to the end.'
—Philip Pullman, Book of the Year, New Statesman
'This is the most extraordinary book. It's got evidence on every page of a mind that is stocked so richly and has meditated so long and so clearly on the most important subject we can face. I can't recommend it enough: it's an astonishing book, that will change many, many people's lives.'
—Philip Pullman, speaking at the How To Academy, 9 November 2021
'Though not quite yet a household name, Iain McGilchrist is leading a quiet but far-reaching revolution in the understanding of who we are as human beings, one with potentially momentous consequences for many of the preoccupations - from ecology and health care to economics and artificial intelligence - that weigh on our present and darken our future ... McGilchrist turns to the resources at our disposal ... to encourage us to 'reconceive our world, our reality', to 'learn again to see'... this means engaging at length and at a high level of abstract argument with competing philosophical theories of truth, rationality, knowledge, perception and being. For philosophically-trained readers, those at least who would adhere to Friedrich Waismann's conviction that "at the heart of any philosophy worth the name is vision", this central thread of the book is deeply satisfying ... Though The Matter With Things contains much detailed and rigorous argument, it is, as its author says at the outset, less an argument properly speaking than a plea for openness to what reality, once our taste for precision and exploitation is set aside, can teach us ... a hugely ambitious vision without parallel in contemporary thought.'
—Professor Ronan Sharkey, Faculty of Philosophy, Institut Catholique de Paris, writing in The Tablet
'This book is an event. McGilchrist has written an astonishing, comprehensive work, of a kind the world has barely seen since the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries... I'd urge readers - unreservedly - to get and read The Matter with Things. The basic truth of McGilchrist's vision is of FUNDAMENTAL importance for our time. It sheds a profound light on ... so many literally vital questions. If it were widely heeded, then perhaps, even at this late hour, our civilisation's merry march to a brutal suicide might be halted. For this book is that most valuable of possible books: it is a work of genius, diagnosing our dire predicament pretty much in full; and (following Lao Tzu) offering a way, instead.'
— Rupert Read, Professor of Philosophy, University of East Anglia, writing in Philosophical Investigations
'It is worth emphasising how rigorous, wide-ranging and well-evidenced McGilchrist's work is. His polymathic mind is on full display in The Matter with Things ... an extraordinary achievement, beautifully produced, clearly written, and peppered with good-quality illustrations.'
—Nick Spencer, Senior Fellow and Director of Research at the Theos Foundation, writing in Prospect
Product details
- ASIN : B09KY5B3QL
- Publisher : Perspectiva Press (November 9, 2021)
- Publication date : November 9, 2021
- Language : English
- File size : 26.6 MB
- Text-to-Speech : Enabled
- Enhanced typesetting : Enabled
- X-Ray : Enabled
- Word Wise : Enabled
- Print length : 2998 pages
- Best Sellers Rank: #202,963 in Kindle Store (See Top 100 in Kindle Store)
- Customer Reviews:
About the author

Dr Iain McGilchrist is a psychiatrist, neuroscience researcher, philosopher and literary scholar. He is a Quondam Fellow of All Souls College, Oxford, a Fellow of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, and former Consultant Psychiatrist and Clinical Director at the Bethlem Royal & Maudsley Hospital, London.
He has been a Research Fellow in neuroimaging at Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore and a Fellow of the Institute of Advanced Studies in Stellenbosch. He has published original articles and research papers in a wide range of publications on topics in literature, philosophy, medicine and psychiatry.
He is the author of a number of books, but is best-known for The Master and his Emissary: The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World (Yale 2009), and The Matter with Things: Our Brains, Our Delusions and the Unmaking of the World (Perspective 2021).
He lives on the Isle of Skye, has two daughters and a son, and now grandchildren.
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the book insightful and explains life, the universe, and everything. They praise the writing quality as remarkable and accessible. The pacing is described as interesting, thought-provoking, engaging, and profound. Readers consider it worth the time and effort. The book covers new ground in two thick volumes. It provides a cohesive hypothesis and a workable strategy. Customers appreciate the book's beauty and layout.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Select to learn more
Customers find the book an insightful and thought-provoking read. They say it explains life, the universe, and everything. The book is described as a true tour de force of scholarly work that covers areas of metaphysical thought and neuroscience.
"...Using neuroscience, physics, metaphysics, evolution, an understanding of consciousness, intuition, imagination, reason, science, philosophy and the..." Read more
"...This said, reading the book is delight because of the erudition, even if you do not agree on every single point...." Read more
"...Overall, it is a vast tome and delves into an interesting theory about the mind and brain. It is not that he should have stopped after part II...." Read more
"...This two-volume set by Ian McGilchrist is an in-depth analysis of the duality of the left hemisphere and right hemisphere physiology of the brain,..." Read more
Customers find the writing quality remarkable and accessible. They appreciate the author's plain, friendly style. The book is described as challenging yet pleasurable to read, with insightful pages that illuminate an integrated vision of life. Readers describe it as a masterwork of humble brilliance that takes them on clear, coherent paths into the enchanted world.
"...It may be helpful to take notes and perhaps to view the chapter videos on the McGilchrist website...." Read more
"...This level is dispersed all over the content of the book. It shows exceptionally clear how the two-hemisphere hypothesis interweaves with several of..." Read more
"We can all benefit from McGilchrist’s thorough, clear and far-reaching thinking...." Read more
"...It is written with thoroughness and detailed scholarship that is reflected in a bibliography that is itself over 300 pages...." Read more
Customers find the book engaging and thought-provoking. They describe it as profound and important, with detailed encounters from an experienced neurologist. The topic is vast and complex, drawing on major intellectual endeavors while giving room for religious perspectives. Overall, readers find the book enjoyable.
"The Matter with Things is more than a book. It is an intellectual foundation for a world that can value truth, beauty, and goodness...." Read more
"We can all benefit from McGilchrist’s thorough, clear and far-reaching thinking...." Read more
"...Thank you for sharing your insights. I have discovered many new and ancient concepts and increased my vocabulary immensely...." Read more
"...I found the reading challenging and intensely pleasurable. In the top few books I have ever read." Read more
Customers find the book worth the time and effort. They describe it as an amazing, important, and compelling master work. The second part is also very enjoyable for them. It's a wonderful follow-up to The Master and His Emissary, but even wider-ranging.
"...intellectual foundation for a world that can value truth, beauty, and goodness...." Read more
"...The second part also very compelling and gravitates towards my own taste; where McGilchrist levies how this theory has impacted many of the i..." Read more
"We can all benefit from McGilchrist’s thorough, clear and far-reaching thinking...." Read more
"...Together, they constitute a true master work...." Read more
Customers find the book's length impressive. They describe it as a vast tome that covers new ground. The book has an introduction, 28 chapters, an epilogue, and 8 appendices. It comes in two thick volumes with attractive covers.
"...The book comes in 3 parts, with an introduction, 28 chapters, an epilogue, 8 appendices, and a 200-page bibliography...." Read more
"...Overall, it is a vast tome and delves into an interesting theory about the mind and brain. It is not that he should have stopped after part II...." Read more
"This is a brilliant and thought-provoking book...and it provides a long (and sometimes obsessively detailed) slog through an immense amount of..." Read more
"...They are huge, thick books with attractive covers and small print. If these are topics that interest you, these books will be enjoyable...." Read more
Customers find the book useful and wise. They mention it covers new ground, has a cohesive hypothesis, and a workable strategy. The book is described as engaging and well worth reading.
"...imagination, reason, science, philosophy and the sacred, the work is wonderful and wise but also long and complex...." Read more
"...from multiple disciplines that form a cohesive hypothesis and a workable strategy for obtaining an understanding of almost everything...." Read more
"Even though a wonderful, indeed incredible piece of work with many strengths and well worth reading, I could not give The Matter With Things five..." Read more
"...that, philosophical content aside, is so physically appealing and useful, that your intuition tells you that the price you paid..." Read more
Customers appreciate the book's layout and style. They find it well-presented and easy to follow.
"...It is an intellectual foundation for a world that can value truth, beauty, and goodness...." Read more
"...He leaves few stones unturned. The books (2 volumes) are beautifully laid out in a way that makes following footnotes incredibly easy..." Read more
"...two volumes, its polymath author welcomes readers with his plain, friendly style...." Read more
"...They are huge, thick books with attractive covers and small print. If these are topics that interest you, these books will be enjoyable...." Read more
Customers enjoy the book's physics. They mention it covers human make-up, religion, and philosophy.
"...slog through an immense amount of neuroscience, philosophy, physics, linguistics/etymology...and other fields as well...." Read more
"...Covering the fields of Neuroscience, Physics, Biology, Philosophy and Theology (and much besides), McGilchrist meticulously builds a cogent case for..." Read more
"A very thorough look at society, human make-up, religion, physics, and philosophy...." Read more
Reviews with images

An intellectual foundation
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United States on November 11, 2022The Matter with Things is more than a book. It is an intellectual foundation for a world that can value truth, beauty, and goodness. Using neuroscience, physics, metaphysics, evolution, an understanding of consciousness, intuition, imagination, reason, science, philosophy and the sacred, the work is wonderful and wise but also long and complex. It asks the questions – How do we know what is true? What account of reality emerges? And who are we as individual beings and as a species? It does this in part by examining Our Brains, Our Delusions, and the Unmaking of the World (the book’s subtitle). The book comes in 3 parts, with an introduction, 28 chapters, an epilogue, 8 appendices, and a 200-page bibliography. It may be helpful to take notes and perhaps to view the chapter videos on the McGilchrist website. These one hour videos are records of conversations between Iain McGilchrist and Alex Gomez-Marin on topics in the book’s chapters. I found them helpful in developing my own understanding of the material when reviewing my notes though they would probably only be marginally helpful without reading the chapters first.
My aim in the rest of this review is to make them about us, about our common humanity, and the gift that is The Matter with Things. We can be manipulative and attentive, selfish and generous, fearful and courageous, callous and compassionate. We more easily see these things in others. My hope is that these three meditations will perhaps provide an opportunity to see them in ourselves as well as to see them in the whole human enterprise. The first two meditations have taken their themes from The Matter with Things. The Left and Right in their titles refer both to our asymmetric brain hemispheres, that is to our neuroanatomy, as well as what’s left to us plus what we get right.
Two notes may be helpful before you read the poems. The simile “like fools with a map” is in the first poem. The point here is that the fools have the map but miss the experience and reality that the map, whether graphics, words, ideas, just represents. In the third line of the final meditation, “My humanity is caught up in yours,” is Desmond Tutu’s translation of the Zulu word Ubuntu.
We Are What Is Left
Lions and tigers and bears, oh my
Language and logic and lies
Fictions seem to last longer than the truth
which is always derivative in this world
of either/or and the land of certainty,
built on shifting sand. It is the home of egos
and some of survival’s necessities.
Like a vision with blinders,
we just name things – this is…
You are…
They will…
Nouns name; that’s all.
These little thoughts are in fast company.
Easy are these directions without depth.
Though many voices speak,
one voice says – this way –
mistaking representation for reality.
We might get comfortable living here
in this place where our home is not,
where all seems locally linear.
The time measured here eats his children,
and this servant can control the master.
Love can sometimes find a space,
and perhaps fear always does.
Do we believe stardust can always start over?
We Are What Is Right
Moving and fishing and flow, oh my
Integration is both more difficult for us
than deriving and is a softer presence
in this, our home of both/and.
It is at first liminal, then shared,
and then renewed, for a time whole and healed.
Presence and the integral are related to that
and that to the flow. Waiting at the gates
of heaven, may we find dancing and laughter and joy.
The beginning of wisdom is awe at God’s presence.
(or as it is written, the fear of the Lord)
We can take time and take our place too
as well as taking only what we need
while queing up to be integrated.
Space is connected and will be made whole.
May we find the fullness to grow
in word and grow in silence,
in the light and in the dark,
in waves of rainbows, music, and time.
Waters of Life
Will a time of compassion begin?
Stand or sit or kneel and be forgiven.
My humanity is caught up in yours.
Let us find Shalom.
May you live in the grace,
whose path is looking informed by love.
though love is not a thing but a verb.
May you find your peace with uncertainty
and also with the feeling of fullness
that is prayer.
Be free to stumble and rise again.
Find yourself at home.
Let all judgments take into account
the many others in these experiments
with seeing and thought,
with language and intuition and imagination.
Our long journeys toward wholeness are similar
May they be safe places
for souls to show up.
5.0 out of 5 starsThe Matter with Things is more than a book. It is an intellectual foundation for a world that can value truth, beauty, and goodness. Using neuroscience, physics, metaphysics, evolution, an understanding of consciousness, intuition, imagination, reason, science, philosophy and the sacred, the work is wonderful and wise but also long and complex. It asks the questions – How do we know what is true? What account of reality emerges? And who are we as individual beings and as a species? It does this in part by examining Our Brains, Our Delusions, and the Unmaking of the World (the book’s subtitle). The book comes in 3 parts, with an introduction, 28 chapters, an epilogue, 8 appendices, and a 200-page bibliography. It may be helpful to take notes and perhaps to view the chapter videos on the McGilchrist website. These one hour videos are records of conversations between Iain McGilchrist and Alex Gomez-Marin on topics in the book’s chapters. I found them helpful in developing my own understanding of the material when reviewing my notes though they would probably only be marginally helpful without reading the chapters first.An intellectual foundation
Reviewed in the United States on November 11, 2022
My aim in the rest of this review is to make them about us, about our common humanity, and the gift that is The Matter with Things. We can be manipulative and attentive, selfish and generous, fearful and courageous, callous and compassionate. We more easily see these things in others. My hope is that these three meditations will perhaps provide an opportunity to see them in ourselves as well as to see them in the whole human enterprise. The first two meditations have taken their themes from The Matter with Things. The Left and Right in their titles refer both to our asymmetric brain hemispheres, that is to our neuroanatomy, as well as what’s left to us plus what we get right.
Two notes may be helpful before you read the poems. The simile “like fools with a map” is in the first poem. The point here is that the fools have the map but miss the experience and reality that the map, whether graphics, words, ideas, just represents. In the third line of the final meditation, “My humanity is caught up in yours,” is Desmond Tutu’s translation of the Zulu word Ubuntu.
We Are What Is Left
Lions and tigers and bears, oh my
Language and logic and lies
Fictions seem to last longer than the truth
which is always derivative in this world
of either/or and the land of certainty,
built on shifting sand. It is the home of egos
and some of survival’s necessities.
Like a vision with blinders,
we just name things – this is…
You are…
They will…
Nouns name; that’s all.
These little thoughts are in fast company.
Easy are these directions without depth.
Though many voices speak,
one voice says – this way –
mistaking representation for reality.
We might get comfortable living here
in this place where our home is not,
where all seems locally linear.
The time measured here eats his children,
and this servant can control the master.
Love can sometimes find a space,
and perhaps fear always does.
Do we believe stardust can always start over?
We Are What Is Right
Moving and fishing and flow, oh my
Integration is both more difficult for us
than deriving and is a softer presence
in this, our home of both/and.
It is at first liminal, then shared,
and then renewed, for a time whole and healed.
Presence and the integral are related to that
and that to the flow. Waiting at the gates
of heaven, may we find dancing and laughter and joy.
The beginning of wisdom is awe at God’s presence.
(or as it is written, the fear of the Lord)
We can take time and take our place too
as well as taking only what we need
while queing up to be integrated.
Space is connected and will be made whole.
May we find the fullness to grow
in word and grow in silence,
in the light and in the dark,
in waves of rainbows, music, and time.
Waters of Life
Will a time of compassion begin?
Stand or sit or kneel and be forgiven.
My humanity is caught up in yours.
Let us find Shalom.
May you live in the grace,
whose path is looking informed by love.
though love is not a thing but a verb.
May you find your peace with uncertainty
and also with the feeling of fullness
that is prayer.
Be free to stumble and rise again.
Find yourself at home.
Let all judgments take into account
the many others in these experiments
with seeing and thought,
with language and intuition and imagination.
Our long journeys toward wholeness are similar
May they be safe places
for souls to show up.
Images in this review
- Reviewed in the United States on January 30, 2022After 10+ years McGilchrist published a sequel to The Master and His Emissary. The new book is even bigger: about 1.500 pages. In the Kindle edition it is 3000 pages of which 2000 as the main text and the rest is appendices, bibliography and endnotes. So it is not a hill, but a mountain to climb.
You can read it on different levels. One is that of the psychopathology of the brain halves. Part I is almost entirely dedicated to show what the different hemispheres, left (LH) and right (RH) do, what and how their respective take is on reality, where things can go wrong, and what then happens, and how dominance of the LH in an uncanny way corresponds with texts and utterances of several famous philosophers and physicists, which is not a good sign.
Another level is as a Kulturkritik, by which I mean that the book shows how the different takes of the hemispheres and the dominance of LH have shaped our current world and why this is very worrying. This level is dispersed all over the content of the book. It shows exceptionally clear how the two-hemisphere hypothesis interweaves with several of the societal and worldwide crises that we face.
A third level is that of a philosophic search for the ways of gaining true knowledge. This level expands into metaphysics, later on into mysticism and in the last chapter into a search after the ground of being. This level that in itself is many layered, is mainly part II and III.
For some people, like me, all levels are very interesting. But when you are a climate activist, or a politician for that mater, the second level might be the most interesting. But although McGilchrist extensively shows the dangers of the current dominance of the LH, no action plan is to be seen. If you are an activist of some sort, imagination/fancy might lead you easily into any planning to go to the barricades, and this is, I feel, just the pitfall that will lead to further dominance of LH. McGilchrist explains the urgency of a rebalancing the LH and RH, but gives no explicite answer, although the answers are, I think, implicite in the text.
He takes quite another turn to metaphysical epistemology (if this is not a contradictio in terminis) that is not for everyone. But he writes beautiful pages on many topics, especially the ones on values. From it I sense a deep Metaphysical Heimweh, which could explain the outcome (i.e. God/god/g’d, although not the Christian one, it is more the general idea of the mysterium tremendum et fascinans of Rudolf Otto, which he mentions only in passing) that, I guess, is only for (the) very few. Such, while as I feel it, insight in the pushes and pulls of the RH and LH, and their take of reality is the real key to a fast-learning track of self-awareness, which is: ‘Know Thyself!’, the adage of the Delphi Oracle. I ask myself if here McGilchrist did not try to stack up up to much hay, so to speak, in one book. Here I sense that the different takes that the reader can take to the book do not always sit well together. You might love one part of the approach, and disagree deeply with another part of it.
I agree with any conclusion that rebalancing LH and RH is in the end an individual matter, but culture as a whole shapes us as well as we shape culture, so there is an equally important collective problem here.
This said, reading the book is delight because of the erudition, even if you do not agree on every single point. McGilchrist seems to me one of those very precious homines universales, as from a bygone era. It might be his Magmum Opus.
McGilchrist quotes, agreeing, Sir Arthur Eddington: ‘We have found a strange footprint on the shores of the unknown … we have succeeded in reconstructing the creature that made the footprint. An Lo! Its our own’. (p 1691 Kindle) But he leaves it at that.
So, for me in the end it is us! At the end of the quest I do not find god/God/g’d, but I find us and me, humanity in all its greatness and shortcomings. It is from us that the move has to come to honour the master (RH) and show the emissary (LH) its rightful place. This should not be a battle with a winner and a looser, or a wobbly truce that has to be closely guarded. In the end it is us that need to acknowledge that we belong to Nature in every sense you can think of, that Nature isn’t ours, but we are Nature’s. If we do not understand this no God or mysterium can help us. It is up to us alone!
But then how difficult is this? The imbalance between LH and RH has happened before. I feel that RH, to stay in the metaphor, has been lured by LH to a dark place, but RH afterall is the Master, who will take his rightful place. It might be a wild ride for some time to come, and we might be too late, but if not, I am not afraid about the outcome. It only asks for a change of paradigm that many are willing to make, but collectivily is a much harder turnaround. But this is personal
Jan Willem van Ee
The Netherlands
- Reviewed in the United States on June 1, 2024This book is split into two volumes, but also three parts:
The first part was a detailed analysis of how he came to realize his theory of an imbalance between the two hemispheres. Although a bit dry for my taste. It was thorough and convincing, an idea all brain scientists should consider.
The second part also very compelling and gravitates towards my own taste; where McGilchrist levies how this theory has impacted many of the i institutions of our society, most notably science. Too caught up in the minutia of facts, we fail to see the big picture, and this has corrupted our view of truth.
The third part, however, fails to impress for me, as a philosopher. I feel that he was a bit of a fish out of water here. For instance, he labels Zeno's Paradox (and many other paradoxes) as "left-brain thinking." But he fails to understand the intellectual advantages of considering the illogical.
He begins to use left-hemisphere thinking as a cudgel in this part. Whereas in the other two parts, he was merely outlining an idea and its consequences in our society. Here it felt like he was flailing around (like so many do), but never finding a raft to ultimately hold onto.
Overall, it is a vast tome and delves into an interesting theory about the mind and brain. It is not that he should have stopped after part II. But that he should have deeply considered opposing arguments in part III, instead of just highlighting all his favorite quotes that seem to agree with him.
A tremendous achievement, although it came to us with a seriously flawed part III.
- Reviewed in the United States on February 11, 2025We can all benefit from McGilchrist’s thorough, clear and far-reaching thinking. A wonderful follow-up to The Master and His Emissary, but even wider ranging.
Top reviews from other countries
- Amazon CustomerReviewed in Canada on May 17, 2023
5.0 out of 5 stars A masterwork!
I have finally finished this 1500 page behemoth. This is McGilchrist's follow up to his previous work "The Master and his Emissary". In "The Matter with Things", McGilchrist beefs up his evidence based analysis of the differences between the function of our left and right hemisphere, a division of the central nervous system that exists in some capacity throughout the animal kingdom. McGilchrist draws on the neurological, psychological and psychiatric literature to illustrate the function of each hemisphere and to draw his conclusions. Once again, as in his previous work, he concludes that the left hemisphere is an analytical processor that divides the world into functional bits so as to gain a survival advantage and manipulate the world, achieving a form of satisfying certainty and avoiding ambiguity. The left hemisphere likes the world "cut and dried". The right hemisphere is a parallel processor that holds onto the big picture, avoids pigeon holing reality and checks the work of the left hemisphere, as the actual world is not nearly as "cut and dried" as the left hemisphere would like it to be. The right hemisphere is more intuitive and able to feel into the rhythms of life. It appreciates art and poetry and revels in the wonder of the great mystery of life. Without the right hemispheres support, the left hemisphere is vulnerable to delusion, false certainty and hubris. McGilchrist once again, points out how our modern world has fallen into the grips of the left hemispheres worldview.
What McGilchrist adds in this latest book, beyond further substantiating the argument made in the last book, is a detailed review of the philosophical tenets of how we come to understand "reality" including the pathways of science, reason, intuition and imagination. He goes on to explore the stuff of which "reality": consists, including time, space, motion, matter and consciousness. McGilchrist reveals to us the perspective of each hemisphere and ultimately presents us with paradox after paradox, arguing for a view of reality that unites and resolves each paradox. Life and matter are not what they first appear to be. We are a process, facing resistance, a constant flow that only appears to be material. We can scale our perception from the tiny to the cosmic and perceive a part of a whole or a whole containing parts at any level of analysis, each level disappearing into the next. Here McGilchrist comes into perfect alignment with Ken Wilber, who he does not reference, and may never have read. McGilchrist draws on a vast number of references in the scientific and philosophical realm. He has produced a masterwork of philosophy. He comes to very satisfying but suitably non dual "conclusions" about the nature of reality, god, being, beauty, goodness, truth, religion and the nature of good and evil. This is a very challenging and extremely lengthy book, but I believe it is truly one of the masterworks of our age and perhaps of any age. Highly recommend to those prepared to take the time and effort. (For those less scientifically and medically minded perhaps skim the chapters in part one.)
-
Gustavo ValencaReviewed in Brazil on January 6, 2023
5.0 out of 5 stars The Matter with Things
Um dos livros mais importantes da década.
- B. HagerfReviewed in Sweden on September 20, 2024
5.0 out of 5 stars A Coup-de-maître & a Tour-de-force
Everyone should try to read this masterpiece - indispensable and profound.
Multi enim sunt vocati, pauci vero electi.
- tomReviewed in France on August 29, 2024
5.0 out of 5 stars The deepest wisdom of our age, expressed with modesty and total frankness
The clear message, argued patiently, brilliantly and humorously over many many pages, is "wake up now or we will take humanity and all other beings in mother earth down with us". I feel impotent to act on more than a personal level. Would that others be more effective. Thank you Iain
- Amazon KundeReviewed in Germany on January 29, 2024
5.0 out of 5 stars Brilliant and essential - embedding the LH's need for clarity in RH wisdom and love
Practical matters first: I accidentally only received Volume I, but Amazon Service was able to solve the problem in one brief phone call (phone call was essential though, the chatbot did not help).
-----
This is very likely the most brilliant and the most important book I have read in the past 30 years, if not in my life. It might just hold the answer we should desperately be searching for in the metacrisis we find ourselves in in just this moment in time.
I believe this book is essential in understanding that the crises we are experiencing are results of our one-sided view of reality, dominated by the utilitarian, mechanistic LH logic, and that we must reign it in with the integrative wisdom and intelligence of our underused RH capacity that sees, understands and connects with the more beautiful, complex and potent reality that is worth living in - and saving.
It is a huge undertaking, but I absolutely recommend reading it. Bring time (and a pencil). It is beautifully written, with an enormous amount of detailed information, brilliantly contextualised and embedded not in analysis alone, but in deep thought and wisdom, and expressed in a language of beauty, precision, and straightforward clarity that makes it a joy to read! It is structured to make it more easily accessible. The introduction is a perfect start. I followed it up with excursions into the chapters I was most intrigued by (Schizophrenia and Autism being the one that stood out most). I followed that up by the chapter summaries, and then finally took a deep breath and started reading it all, beginning at page one.
Reading it almost comes as a healing intervention to me - a reconciliation with the painful experience of being educated within a LH-dominated system that forced me to dissociated from the more beautiful, complex and alive world I knew intuitively to be true. I have cried my way through many of the chapters, finding so much of my intuitive understanding of the world and so many of my clashes with how it is seen and managed in science and in our dominant western governance models and narratives laid out and understood with such clarity, intelligence, integrity and tenderness.
Iain McGilchrist puts the necessary (!) LH view of reality in its place without alienating it. Instead he puts it in context and offers an integration, an embrace by RH's wisdom. He reconciles, and opens the potential to integrate our intelligence and be in and of the world with awe, care, and joy. Beautiful and essential.